The truth about liquid diets: are they damaging your health?

by Laura Forsyth | 27th June, 2023 | Nutrition

Liquid diets have taken the weight loss world by storm, promising quick and effortless results. But are these trendy diets really as beneficial as they claim, or do they pose a threat to our overall well-being? Here, we’re diving deep into the truth about liquid diets to separate fact from fiction and shed light on their potential risks. 

What is a liquid diet?

Before we delve into the pros and cons, let’s first understand what a liquid diet actually entails. Essentially, a liquid diet involves replacing solid foods with liquids, such as shakes, juices, soups, and smoothies. These diets often restrict or eliminate solid food intake altogether, relying solely on liquid nutrition.

Is it sustainable? The downside of quick fixes

One of the main attractions of liquid diets is their promise of rapid weight loss. While it’s true that you may shed pounds quickly in the beginning, the sustainability of such rapid weight loss is questionable. The truth is, quick fixes rarely lead to long-term success. Moreover, drastic and rapid weight loss can have negative effects on your metabolism and overall well-being. 

READ MORE: Is Meal Prep Delivery Cheaper than Buying Ingredients from the Supermarket?

Nutrient deficiencies: are you getting enough?

One of the biggest concerns surrounding liquid diets is the potential for nutrient deficiencies. By limiting or eliminating solid foods, you may not be getting the full spectrum of essential nutrients your body needs to function optimally. From vitamins and minerals to fibre and protein, the lack of proper nutrition can have serious consequences for your health.

There are potentially even more dangerous side effects as leafy greens and other common juiced foods contain oxalate and overconsuming this can become toxic. Research shows one example where a man’s excessive juicing habits even led to kidney failure. 

READ MORE: The Vegan Diet: Busting the top 3 most searched myths

Muscle loss: preserving your strength

Another drawback of liquid diets is the potential for muscle loss. When you restrict your calorie intake and rely solely on liquid nutrition, your body may start breaking down muscle tissue for energy. This can lead to a loss of strength and a decrease in metabolic rate.

To combat muscle loss, incorporating adequate protein and engaging in resistance training is crucial. With some liquid diets even going as low as 500 to 800 calories a day, it’s likely you’ll feel light-headed or dizzy with headaches, digestive issues and depleted energy levels.

Psychological effects: is your mind in balance?

 While the physical effects of liquid diets are concerning, their psychological impact shouldn’t be overlooked either. Strictly adhering to liquid diets can create disordered eating patterns and an unhealthy relationship with food.

The restrictive nature of these diets may also lead to feelings of deprivation, frustration, and even contribute to emotional distress. Liquid diets are often intended for those about to undergo surgery after all, and patients are usually closely monitored by a health professional. 

Just to add to the potential mental and physical risks, most trendy liquid diets aren’t too great on the bank balance either. Some juices can range from £15-20 per bottle and all-inclusive juice deals can be much more!